“When somebody’s wearing a mask, he’s gonna tell you the truth. When he’s not wearing a mask, it’s highly unlikely.” - Bob, echoing Oscar Wilde.
Here’s the thing about Ai: if you ask it to write a letter from Bing Crosby, it’ll do it. It might not spew out a letter that would fool someone who’s studied actual letters from Bing, but it’ll go out of its way to make sure anyone reading it gets the speaker here is Bing Crosby. It’ll make some references to his career and biography, and probably some fascinating facts (“I recorded ‘White Christmas’ in 18 minutes, you know.”)
Bob Dylan has now posted over 40 “letters never sent” from various historical figures to other historical figures, ruminating on art, society, politics, and the loneliness of celebrities to his patreon. They’ve been largely ignored by the fandom, as most are convinced that some level of Ai is being used to write the stories and letters there. I’ve seen various reasons for this - the graphics advertising them are clearly Ai, there are too many of them for him to have written them himself (ha!), they’re punctuated too well, or they’re all pretty close to the same length. Or, worse, some Ai-checker said they were Ai.
Those checkers are useless. Even the bots that generate some sort of watermark don’t really distinguish from stuff where a robot did all of the writing from those where it did some proofreading (something Ai is surprisingly bad at) or reformatting (which is pretty good at). I’ve played with it enough to get a feel for what it can and can’t do pretty well.
There’s no way to say there isn’t Ai someplace in the DNA of these letters - we all know Dylan isn’t picky about where he finds the limbs, livers, brains, and hearts that he uses for the creatures that he creates.
But none of the things I’d expect from asking Ai to write a letter from, say, Babe Ruth to Allen Ginsberg ever comes up in them. Minus the occasional toss-off reference to “my movies” or “when I’m up at the plate,” they all seem to be coming from the same person, espousing the same broad worldviews. And it all sounds like the same guy who wrote Philosophy of Modern Song. And, though he’s putting other names on it and not doing much to stop us from thinking he’s just playing with a computer, I think he’s putting out a lot of his own thoughts and feelings into these.
This began in the early letter from James Baldwin to Walt Disney, taking him to task for whitewashing American history and society. And though he skipped the question of “advice for Donald Trump” in the recent New York Times survey of octogenarians, it was easy to see the letter from Chopin to the gangster Frank Costello: “Even a badly tuned piano possesses more integrity: when struck, it declares exactly what it is. You, sir, are all pedal and no melody, prolonging noise after the soul has vanished…. dawn belongs to those who create rather than consume. When your name is dust in a sealed ledger, my weakest prelude will still command more loyalty than your strongest lieutenant.”
I doubt Dylan would want to deal with the media and clickbait that would follow if he said that about any current politician directly, but hiding it in a letter from a dead composer to a dead gangster is enough of a mask that he can say his thing and not be bothered.
This is true of many of the letters. I don’t doubt that what Humphrey Bogart says to Elvis (“You’ve got something most men would sell their souls for… But instead of sharpening it into something dangerous, you’ve let it get wrapped up in glitter…and handlers who treat you like a slot machine that never stops paying out”) is exactly what Bob would have said to him at one point or another.
Not all of the letters are masterpieces, and lately they’ve gotten a bit repetitive, with one letter after another about the strange loneliness that comes to artists after the applause dies down for the night, the point when an artist hears the echoes more than the applause, or the need to keep a private version of yourself separate from a public persona. But these, I have no doubt, are subjects on which Bob ruminates often and has a lot to say.
I’ve played enough with Ai to have opinions on it, and to recognize a bit of what it can and can’t do. What it’s especially good at is scams. It can trick you very well, in such a way that soon we won’t have any writing or music that can’t be accused of being Ai. I’ve already loved songs that turned out to be entirely the work of robots (and one, a really dirty Irish folk song, is stuck in my head right now, to my horror). I get about a dozen well-presented attempts to scam me every day, and a most days even couple of letters from “ai agents” offering to do my research for me for $25 and insisting that they can access microfilm reels and unscanned old ledgers (which they can’t). I get convincing-sounding letters from other authors, agents, publicists, and book club organizers, sometimes talking about my newest book and sometimes about old ones. A couple managed to convince me for a few emails until they started in with the scams. Sometimes they have more insightful comments on my work than my editors did.
One thing they absolutely can do is imitate Babe Ruth. And the “Letters Never Sent.” aren’t doing that.
Just a note: speaking of scams, I clicked a link I shouldn’t have to try out a program that could help me automate ads for my walking tours - a tedious job that seems like it could be a lot more automated than it is. It quickly turned out to be some slop, so I deleted it and changed a few passwords, but I got some messages at 4:06am that said my Facebook account may have been hacked, and by 4:11 the account was disabled. I’m currently trying to establish - to Meta’s ai bots - that whatever got me disabled was a hacker. It should be obvious to anyone that I didn’t log in from New York at 4:05, from Vietnam at 4:06, and then attempt to login from Chicago an hour later. But you can’t talk to a person at Meta, so my Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp are currently shut down. It’s terrible timing, as those are my most reliable places to advertise cemetery tours, for which it’s currently the busy season.
At least my own Patreon (Chicago history stuff) is still up!

Agree. These things are masterpieces, insightful and a wonderful look into the mind we all want to look into. When the book version comes out everyone will go nuts - now a ridiculous silence. Glad you’re talking them up.